Get the free Morris County Fall Bucket List
60+ of the best things to do across Morris County this fall. Apple picking, corn mazes, hayrides, fall festivals, haunted attractions and cider donuts. Straight to your inbox, free.
Quick answer: The oldest restaurant in Morris County is the Black Horse Tavern and Pub in Mendham, serving since 1742. Other long running spots still open include the 1810 Brick Tavern in Chester (now PH Steakhouse), Rod’s Steak and Seafood Grille in Convent Station (1951), Arthur’s Tavern in Morris Plains (1957), Enzo’s in Budd Lake (1976) and The Grand Café in Morristown (1981).
New restaurants open in Morris County every month, and we love covering them. But there is something special about sitting down in a dining room that has been feeding this county for generations, where your grandparents may have celebrated the same birthday you are celebrating tonight.
Here are six of Morris County’s oldest restaurants and taverns that are still serving today, ranked from oldest to newest, with the dish to order at each. Every founding year comes from the restaurant itself or from the county, and every spot was confirmed open this fall. For the bakeries, farms and theaters that have been around even longer, see our guide to the oldest businesses in Morris County.
1. Black Horse Tavern and Pub, Mendham (1742)
The Black Horse calls itself New Jersey’s oldest continually running restaurant, and it has been serving guests on West Main Street since 1742, when Mendham was a stop on the stagecoach road west of Morristown. The property has two sides: the Tavern, the dressier dining room, and the Pub, which started life as the horse stables. A recent renovation freshened up the rooms while preserving the historic building’s character.
What to order: the menu is American classics with a nod to post Revolutionary War cooking, so go for a hearty tavern dinner in the Pub with a pint by the bar.
Address: 1 West Main Street, Mendham
blackhorsenj.com
2. PH Tavern and Steakhouse at the Publick House, Chester (1810)
Zephaniah Drake built this three and a half story brick tavern on Main Street between 1810 and 1812 for stagecoach travelers, and it is now on the National Register of Historic Places. It spent a stretch as a college prep school called the Chester Institute in the 1850s before returning to hospitality. Today the building houses the Publick House Hotel and PH Tavern and Steakhouse, with live music on Wednesday and Friday nights.
What to order: the candied slab bacon to start, then a steak. Wednesday is prime rib night.
Address: 111 Main Street, Chester
Hours: Tuesday to Sunday from noon, closed Monday
phsteakhouse.com
3. Rod’s Steak and Seafood Grille, Convent Station (1951)
Rod’s has been a Morristown area landmark since 1951. Expect classic wood paneling, polished brass and one of the most unusual private dining options in the state: tables inside restored 1800s railroad parlor cars. The wine list runs past 300 bottles and has earned a Wine Spectator Award of Excellence for more than 20 years.
What to order: the signature crab bisque and the roast prime rib, which is made in limited quantity, so book early.
Address: 1 Convent Road, Morristown (Convent Station)
Hours: dinner nightly from 4 p.m.
rodssteak.com
4. Arthur’s Tavern, Morris Plains (1957)
Arthur McGreevy, the man the restaurant still calls the “Legendary Restaurant Man,” started here in 1957 when the building on Speedwell Avenue was the Brook Tavern. In 1985 he turned it into the steakhouse everyone knows, built on giant portions at prices families could afford. It is common to see four generations at one table.
What to order: the 24 ounce Delmonico if you came hungry, or the famous 10 ounce hamburger if you did not.
Address: 700 Speedwell Avenue, Morris Plains
Hours: Monday to Saturday 3 to 9 p.m., Sunday 2 to 9 p.m.
arthurstavern.com
5. Enzo’s Ristorante and Pizzeria, Budd Lake (1976)
Emilio Buonincontri came from Naples, got his start in Brooklyn and opened a pizzeria in Budd Lake in 1976. Fifty years later, his son Ernie and grandson Emilio run it, and the pizza sauce still follows the original 1976 recipe. We sat down with the family for Enzo’s 50th anniversary story this fall.
What to order: the Della Nonna pizza, a thin and crispy Sicilian style pie with homemade marinara, fresh mozzarella and basil.
Address: 382 US Route 46, Budd Lake
enzospizzabuddlake.com
6. The Grand Café, Morristown (1981)
Irish immigrants Desmond and Alice Lloyd opened The Grand Café on July 1, 1981, and it has been downtown Morristown’s go to for French fine dining ever since. Morris County honored the restaurant on its 45th anniversary this summer. Their daughter, Allison Lloyd Porter, now runs it as a second generation family business.
What to order: the Dover sole meunière with brown butter and lemon, or the Grand Café French onion soup.
Address: 42 Washington Street, Morristown
Hours: lunch Tuesday to Friday, dinner Tuesday to Saturday
thegrandcafe.com
Planning a special night out?
Most of these dining rooms book up fast between Thanksgiving and New Year’s, so reserve early. If you want more ideas for an anniversary or date night, our list of the most romantic restaurants in Morris County pairs well with this one, and our Mendham guide covers what to do before dinner at the Black Horse.
Frequently asked questions
What is the oldest restaurant in Morris County?
The Black Horse Tavern and Pub at 1 West Main Street in Mendham, serving since 1742, is the oldest and calls itself New Jersey’s oldest continually running restaurant.
How old is Rod’s Steak and Seafood Grille?
Rod’s has been serving guests in Convent Station since 1951, and it offers private dining in restored 1800s railroad parlor cars.
Which historic Morris County restaurant has a steakhouse in an 1810 building?
PH Tavern and Steakhouse operates inside the Publick House at 111 Main Street in Chester, a brick tavern built between 1810 and 1812 for stagecoach travelers.
Photo: The 1810 Brick Tavern in Chester, home of PH Steakhouse. Zeete, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons.
Have a Morris County event coming up?
Share it with Morris County.
Festivals, fundraisers, 5Ks, school nights, grand openings. Send us the date, time, place and a flyer, and our team will reach out about getting it in front of Morris County.
Enjoying our Morris County coverage?
Add us as a preferred source and our stories show up higher in your Google results.
Add as a preferred source





