Home Community Denville’s The Pasta Shop Named the No. 1 Pasta Place in America on Yelp’s First-Ever Top 100 List
CommunityEat & Drink

Denville’s The Pasta Shop Named the No. 1 Pasta Place in America on Yelp’s First-Ever Top 100 List

Share
Overhead view of handmade pasta dishes at The Pasta Shop in Denville, NJ, including linguine with clams, rigatoni vodka, chicken parm and meatballs
Photo: The Pasta Shop
Share
Veterans Valor NJ, a Morris County nonprofit supporting local veterans

Get the free Morris County Fall Bucket List

60+ of the best things to do across Morris County this fall. Apple picking, corn mazes, hayrides, fall festivals, haunted attractions and cider donuts. Straight to your inbox, free.

Send me the list

The Pasta Shop at 13 First Avenue in Denville has been named the No. 1 pasta place in the United States on Yelp’s first-ever Top 100 Pasta Places list, released this week ahead of National Pasta Day on Saturday, October 17, 2026. The Morris County restaurant finished first out of 100 trattorias, pasta shops and markets nationwide, ahead of Eataliana Homemade Pasta in Shelby Township, Michigan, Forma Pasta Factory in Brooklyn, Albano’s Pasta Shop in Valparaiso, Indiana, and Pasta Fresca in Reno, Nevada, which rounded out the top five.

Yelp built the ranking from its platform data and community reviews. The company said searches for “pasta shops” on Yelp rose more than 50 percent this year compared to the prior 12 months, and its data showed diners are increasingly drawn to spots that combine a restaurant with a place to buy fresh pasta and watch it being made.

The Pasta Shop describes itself as a fine casual neighborhood eatery featuring handmade pastas and wood fired Italian American classics. On Yelp, the restaurant holds a 4.6 star rating across more than 800 reviews, and one reviewer summed up the regulars’ order: “The rigatoni vodka, chicken parm and carbonara are must get entrees.”

It is a true hometown story. Executive chef and co-owner Tommy Pollio was born and raised in Denville and got his start cooking as a teenager at Sergio & Co. He went on to the culinary arts program at Morris County Vo-Tech, then spent more than 15 years in kitchens in North Carolina, Los Angeles, San Francisco and Chicago before coming home to open The Pasta Shop. Co-owner Sergio Sciancalepore, who grew up making mozzarella in his Italian immigrant parents’ specialty stores, opened Sergio & Co. in Denville in 1999 and became known for his fresh mozzarella and oversized sandwiches.

Think your favorite spot deserves a title too?

Voting is open for the Best of Morris County 2026. Pick your favorites in 12 categories before November 30, and every winner gets featured on ShopMorrisCounty.com in December. Cast your vote here.

The Pasta Shop was not the only New Jersey spot to make the cut. Pasta Volo in Asbury Park landed at No. 8, and L&D Sapore Ravioli & Cheese in Middlesex and Mavi’s Pizza and Pasta in Fort Lee also made the Top 100.

If you are planning a visit, The Pasta Shop is open Tuesday through Friday from 3 to 9 p.m. and Saturday from noon to 9 p.m., and is closed Sunday and Monday. Tables are first come, first served, and the restaurant does not take reservations, so expect a wait, especially around National Pasta Day. Pickup orders can be placed through The Pasta Shop’s website or by calling 973-253-4143.

Our guide to things to do in Denville has more to see and eat in town, and our roundup of the best Italian restaurants in Morris County has more red sauce spots worth the drive.

Have a Morris County event coming up?

Share it with Morris County.

Festivals, fundraisers, 5Ks, school nights, grand openings. Send us the date, time, place and a flyer, and our team will reach out about getting it in front of Morris County.

Share your event

Enjoying our Morris County coverage?

Add us as a preferred source and our stories show up higher in your Google results.

Add as a preferred source
Share
Written by
Shop Morris County -

The Shop Morris County editorial team covers events, restaurants, things to do and local news across all 39 Morris County towns. We are locals, and every date, address, price and set of hours we publish is checked against the organizer, the business or the town itself. Read our editorial standards at shopmorriscounty.com/editorial-standards/ or send a tip to info@shopmorriscounty.com.

Shawnee Mountain Ski Area ad: a young skier in black gear and orange goggles carves down a groomed slope under the words Your Winter Starts Here, with the Shawnee Mountain logo and Ski, Ride and Tube, ShawneeMt.com
Lush The Collective East Hanover

Pawfect Journey ad: a tabby cat surrounded by automatic litter boxes with the headline Never Scoop Litter Again and a See the List button for the 13 best automatic litter boxes of 2026
Supreme Office Cleaning, Morris County NJ. Request a free estimate, call 973-292-0123.
Related Articles
Dining room with a brick fireplace and white tablecloths at PH Tavern and Steakhouse at the Publick House in Chester, NJ
Eat & Drink

Morris County’s 6 coziest restaurants with fireplaces, ranked for winter 2026

Six Morris County restaurants where you can dine by a real fireplace...

Woman working on a laptop in her living room, illustrating work from home rates in Morris County NJ towns
CommunityNews

More Than 1 in 5 Morris County Workers Work From Home, and Chatham Borough Leads at 37 Percent

21.8% of Morris County workers work from home, second highest in NJ....

Families sled down a snowy hill lined with frost-covered evergreen trees on a winter day.
CommunityThings To Do

Sledding Hills in Morris County, NJ: Where to Go After a Snowfall

Officially listed sledding hills in Morris County, NJ, with addresses, park rules...

A small shop window filled with Christmas figurines and holiday decorations.
CommunityEventsShopping

Small Business Saturday 2026 in Morris County, NJ: Where to Shop Local on November 28

Small Business Saturday 2026 in Morris County, NJ is November 28. Here...

A roasted Thanksgiving turkey being carved at a dinner table with red wine and sides.
CommunityEat & Drink

Thanksgiving Dinner To Go in Morris County, NJ for 2026: Order Deadlines, Prices and Catering Picks

Every 2026 Thanksgiving dinner to go and catering option we confirmed in...

Green Shop Morris County cover reading The Best Hibachi Restaurants in Morris County, NJ
Eat & DrinkThings To Do

The 5 Best Hibachi Restaurants in Morris County, NJ

The best hibachi restaurants in Morris County, NJ, from Parsippany and Denville...