Home Eat & Drink 6 Best Restaurants in Mendham, NJ (2026 Local Guide)
Eat & DrinkThings To Do

6 Best Restaurants in Mendham, NJ (2026 Local Guide)

Share
Best Restaurants in Mendham, NJ (2026 Local Guide): photo collage with a green Morris County map and a pin on Mendham
Share
Veterans Valor NJ, a Morris County nonprofit supporting local veterans

Get the free Morris County Fall Bucket List

60+ of the best things to do across Morris County this fall. Apple picking, corn mazes, hayrides, fall festivals, haunted attractions and cider donuts. Straight to your inbox, free.

Send me the list

Quick answer: The best Mendham restaurants are the Black Horse Tavern and Pub, New Jersey’s oldest continuously running restaurant, Piattino for a neighborhood Italian bistro dinner, Dante’s Ristorante for homestyle Italian and pizza, Frank’s Pizza for a classic pie, Aoyama for Chinese and Japanese, and Mendham Bagel for breakfast.

Updated November 2026 by the Shop Morris County team

Looking for the best Mendham restaurants? Mendham’s dining is small and close together. Nearly everything sits on Main Street (Route 24), anchored on the west end by a tavern that has been serving since 1742 and on the east end by a cluster of Italian spots, a pizzeria and a bagel shop in the same few plazas. Here are our picks.

Voting is open
Vote for the Best of Morris County 2026
Think we missed your favorite? Cast your vote for the best restaurants in Morris County and help crown this year’s winners.
Vote Now
Voting closes November 30, 2026

Making a day of it? Pair dinner with a hike from our guide to things to do in Mendham, or keep driving west to the best restaurants in Chester.

The Black Horse Tavern and Pub

Dating to 1742, the Black Horse is recognized as New Jersey’s oldest continuously running restaurant, set in an old stagecoach house. It reopened in 2025 after a full renovation that refreshed the kitchen, dining rooms and outdoor space without losing the history. Go for classic American food, the pub side for a casual dinner, and plan on booking ahead for weekends.

Address: 1 W Main St, Mendham, NJ 07945
Cuisine: American, Tavern
Website: blackhorsenj.com

Piattino

A neighborhood Italian bistro in the Kings shopping plaza, with Neapolitan style pizzas, pastas and seafood, a full bar and big front windows looking out onto Main Street. It is the dressier of the town’s Italian options.

Address: 88 E Main St, Mendham, NJ 07945
Cuisine: Italian
Website: piattinonj.com

Dante’s Ristorante

Mendham’s homestyle Italian standby for lunch, dinner and pizza, with a busy takeout counter and a private party room in back. It is the place locals call for a family dinner or a party tray.

Address: 100 E Main St, Mendham, NJ 07945
Phone: (973) 543-5401
Cuisine: Italian, Pizza
Website: dantesnj.com

Frank’s Pizza and Italian Restaurant

An old school pizzeria with slices, full pies and a long menu of Italian dishes at fair prices. Grab a slice after practice or order a few pies for the house.

Address: 86 E Main St, Mendham, NJ 07945
Phone: (973) 543-4180
Cuisine: Pizza, Italian

Aoyama Chinese and Japanese Cuisine

Mendham’s go to for sushi rolls and Chinese takeout in the same East Main Street plaza as Frank’s. It serves lunch and dinner.

Address: 86 E Main St, Suite L, Mendham, NJ 07945
Cuisine: Chinese, Japanese

Mendham Bagel and Coffee Shop

Kettle boiled bagels baked on site with locally roasted coffee. Order a Taylor ham, egg and cheese and you will understand the morning line.

Address: 88 E Main St, Mendham, NJ 07945
Cuisine: Bagels, Breakfast
Website: mendhambagel.com

Just Outside Mendham

Morristown is about 15 minutes east with dozens more options; start with our guide to the best restaurants in Morristown. Randolph and Chester are close by too.

How to Plan a Mendham Food Night

Mendham is easy to do in one stop. Park in the East Main Street plazas for Piattino, Dante’s, Frank’s, Aoyama and the bagel shop, or head to the west end of Main Street for the Black Horse. Fall is a great time to come, when the drive in on Route 24 is lined with color.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the best restaurants in Mendham, NJ?

Our top picks are the Black Horse Tavern and Pub, Piattino, Dante’s Ristorante, Frank’s Pizza and Italian Restaurant, Aoyama Chinese and Japanese Cuisine and Mendham Bagel and Coffee Shop.

What is the oldest restaurant in New Jersey?

The Black Horse Tavern and Pub at 1 West Main Street in Mendham dates to 1742 and is recognized as New Jersey’s oldest continuously running restaurant.

Is the Black Horse Tavern open after the renovation?

Yes. The Black Horse closed in March 2024 for a major renovation and reopened in 2025.

Where can I get breakfast in Mendham?

Mendham Bagel and Coffee Shop at 88 East Main Street bakes its bagels on site and serves locally roasted coffee.

Explore More Morris County Restaurant Guides

Hungry for more? Browse our guides to the best Randolph restaurants, the best restaurants in Long Valley and the oldest businesses in Morris County. Shop Morris County is the largest local guide for Morris County, NJ.

Featured image: photo collage built by Shop Morris County using free stock photos from Pexels.

Have a Morris County event coming up?

Share it with Morris County.

Festivals, fundraisers, 5Ks, school nights, grand openings. Send us the date, time, place and a flyer, and our team will reach out about getting it in front of Morris County.

Share your event

Enjoying our Morris County coverage?

Add us as a preferred source and our stories show up higher in your Google results.

Add as a preferred source
Share
Written by
Shop Morris County -

The Shop Morris County editorial team covers events, restaurants, things to do and local news across all 39 Morris County towns. We are locals, and every date, address, price and set of hours we publish is checked against the organizer, the business or the town itself. Read our editorial standards at shopmorriscounty.com/editorial-standards/ or send a tip to info@shopmorriscounty.com.

Shawnee Mountain Ski Area ad: a young skier in black gear and orange goggles carves down a groomed slope under the words Your Winter Starts Here, with the Shawnee Mountain logo and Ski, Ride and Tube, ShawneeMt.com
Lush The Collective East Hanover

Pawfect Journey ad: a tabby cat surrounded by automatic litter boxes with the headline Never Scoop Litter Again and a See the List button for the 13 best automatic litter boxes of 2026
Supreme Office Cleaning, Morris County NJ. Request a free estimate, call 973-292-0123.
Related Articles
Best Restaurants in Pompton Plains, NJ (2026 Local Guide): photo collage with a green Morris County map and a pin on Pompton Plains
Eat & DrinkThings To Do

6 Best Restaurants in Pompton Plains and Pequannock, NJ (2026 Local Guide)

Best Pompton Plains and Pequannock restaurants for 2026: Pompton Queen Diner, Tavern...

Best Restaurants in Montville, NJ (2026 Local Guide): photo collage with a green Morris County map and a pin on Montville
Eat & DrinkThings To Do

7 Best Restaurants in Montville, NJ (2026 Local Guide)

The best Montville restaurants in 2026: Rails Steakhouse in Towaco, Columbia Inn...

Best Restaurants in Chatham, NJ (2026 Local Guide): photo collage with a green Morris County map and a pin on Chatham
Eat & DrinkThings To Do

7 Best Restaurants in Chatham, NJ (2026 Local Guide)

The best Chatham restaurants for 2026: Scalini Fedeli, Restaurant Serenade, BYOB steak...

Best Restaurants in Boonton, NJ (2026 Local Guide): photo collage with a green Morris County map and a pin on Boonton
Eat & DrinkThings To Do

6 Best Restaurants in Boonton, NJ (2026 Local Guide)

Our 2026 guide to the best Boonton restaurants: Reservoir Tavern pizza, Ombra...

The Best Steakhouses in Morris County, NJ: photo collage with a green Morris County map cutout
Eat & DrinkThings To Do

The Best Steakhouses in Morris County, NJ

From Roots in Morristown to Rails in Towaco, these are the best...

The Best Seafood Restaurants in Morris County, NJ: photo collage with a green Morris County map cutout
Eat & DrinkThings To Do

The Best Seafood Restaurants in Morris County, NJ

From a 1951 fish market to raw bars, sushi, and Cajun boils,...

The 13 Best Restaurants in Parsippany, NJ (2026): photo collage with a green Morris County map cutout
Eat & Drink

The 13 Best Restaurants in Parsippany, NJ (2026)

Updated November 2026 by the Shop Morris County team. Three picks were...

The Best Diners in Morris County, NJ: photo collage with a green Morris County map cutout
Eat & DrinkThings To Do

The Best Diners in Morris County, NJ

From Route 10 classics to 24-hour staples, these are the best diners...