Get the free Morris County Fall Bucket List
60+ of the best things to do across Morris County this fall. Apple picking, corn mazes, hayrides, fall festivals, haunted attractions and cider donuts. Straight to your inbox, free.
Quick answer: The best Pompton Plains restaurants are the Pompton Queen Diner for a classic Jersey diner meal, Tavern 5 for burgers and a neighborhood bar, Pizza Man Trattoria Italiano for BYOB Italian, Stefano’s Ristorante for family Italian, Hoboken’s Pizzeria for pizza and Defying Gravitea in Pequannock for gluten free breakfast and lunch.
Updated November 2026 by the Shop Morris County team
Looking for the best Pompton Plains restaurants? Pompton Plains is part of Pequannock Township in northern Morris County, and its restaurants line two roads: Route 23 and the Newark Pompton Turnpike. It is a family dining town, with a landmark diner, a couple of long running Italian spots, a modern neighborhood tavern and one of the area’s only fully gluten free cafes.
Heading north for the day? Our guides to the best Butler restaurants and the best restaurants in Lincoln Park cover the towns next door.
Pompton Queen Diner
A family owned Route 23 diner since 1982 with a menu that takes a while to read. Breakfast is served all day, the disco fries are a local favorite, and the dessert case is worth a look on your way out.
Address: 710 Route 23, Pompton Plains, NJ 07444
Phone: (973) 835-2086
Cuisine: Diner, American
Website: pomptonqueendiner.com
Tavern 5
The Carbone family turned the former Gilly’s into this neighborhood tavern in 2016. The signature Tavern 5 burger uses a Pat LaFrieda blend with avocado, bacon and pepper jack, and the arancini came back by popular demand.
Address: 710 Newark Pompton Tpke, Pompton Plains, NJ 07444
Cuisine: American, Bar and Grill
Pizza Man Trattoria Italiano
A small BYOB family restaurant in the Clock Tower Shoppes with pizza, sandwiches and a long list of homestyle Italian dinners. It also does catering for parties.
Address: 574 Newark Pompton Tpke, Pompton Plains, NJ 07444
Phone: (973) 835-3383
Cuisine: Italian, Pizza
Stefano’s Ristorante
A family owned Route 23 Italian restaurant that has been serving pasta, pizza and Italian classics to the area for more than 45 years.
Address: 565 Route 23, Pompton Plains, NJ 07444
Cuisine: Italian, Pizza
Hoboken’s Pizzeria
The Mastroianni family opened this pizzeria in the early 1980s, and it has been a Pompton Plains pizza night institution ever since.
Address: 615 Route 23, Pompton Plains, NJ 07444
Cuisine: Pizza, Italian
Defying Gravitea
Opened in 2023 by Pequannock resident Gina R. Cassese, a fifth generation chef, this cafe is entirely gluten and dairy free. It serves breakfast and lunch all day plus a bakeshop case, so it is a safe bet for anyone with food allergies.
Address: 211 Newark Pompton Tpke, Pequannock, NJ 07440
Phone: (862) 226-9692
Cuisine: Cafe, Gluten Free
Just Outside Pompton Plains
Kinnelon and Riverdale are a short drive west on Route 23. See our guides to the best Kinnelon restaurants and things to do in Riverdale.
How to Plan a Pompton Plains Food Night
Pompton Plains restaurants are almost all on Route 23 or the Newark Pompton Turnpike, so most of this list is within a few minutes of each other. Start the day at the Pompton Queen or Defying Gravitea, and save Tavern 5 or a BYOB dinner at Pizza Man for the evening.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best restaurants in Pompton Plains, NJ?
Our top picks are the Pompton Queen Diner, Tavern 5, Pizza Man Trattoria Italiano, Stefano’s Ristorante, Hoboken’s Pizzeria and Defying Gravitea.
Is Pompton Plains part of Pequannock?
Yes. Pompton Plains is a section of Pequannock Township in Morris County, with its own 07444 ZIP code.
Is there a BYOB restaurant in Pompton Plains?
Yes. Pizza Man Trattoria Italiano on the Newark Pompton Turnpike is BYOB.
Where can I find gluten free food in Pequannock?
Defying Gravitea at 211 Newark Pompton Turnpike is fully gluten and dairy free and serves breakfast and lunch all day.
Explore More Morris County Restaurant Guides
Hungry for more? Browse our guides to the best diners in Morris County, the best pizza in Morris County and the best Italian restaurants in Morris County. Shop Morris County is the largest local guide for Morris County, NJ.
Featured image: photo collage built by Shop Morris County using free stock photos from Pexels.
Have a Morris County event coming up?
Share it with Morris County.
Festivals, fundraisers, 5Ks, school nights, grand openings. Send us the date, time, place and a flyer, and our team will reach out about getting it in front of Morris County.
Enjoying our Morris County coverage?
Add us as a preferred source and our stories show up higher in your Google results.
Add as a preferred source





