Best Butler, NJ Restaurants (2026 Guide)

Looking for the best Butler NJ restaurants? You are in the right place. Butler is a small borough in northern Morris County with a walkable Main Street and a busy stretch of Route 23, and between the two you can find a family restaurant that has been in town for more than 50 years, Italian, sushi, Mexican, Indian and a lively neighborhood bar. Here is where we like to eat.

We update this guide regularly to make sure it reflects the latest openings, closures, and standout dining experiences. For more restaurant guides across the county, check out our picks for the best restaurants in Lincoln Park, Denville, Parsippany, and Morristown.

Butler sits right next to Kinnelon, and the two towns share a lot of local life. If you are planning a day in the area, see our guides to things to do in Butler and things to do in Kinnelon, where you can also read about the annual Kinnelon KFest.

Most of the restaurants below are on Main Street, within an easy walk of one another, while Buonasera and Yuki Hana are a short drive away on Route 23.

Butler Family Restaurant

A true hometown spot on Main Street that has been serving the community for more than 50 years. It opens at 7 am, so it is our go to for a classic breakfast, and it stays open through dinner. Dine in, take out and delivery are all available.

Address: 134 Main St, Butler, NJ 07405
Phone: (973) 838-6690
Hours: Wednesday to Monday 7 am to 9 pm, Sunday 7 am to 8 pm, closed Tuesday
Cuisine: American, Breakfast
Website: butlerfamilyrestaurant.com

Buonasera Restaurant

Italian cooking and pizza on Route 23, with long hours seven days a week. It works for everything from a weeknight pizza to a sit down pasta dinner, and it takes online reservations and hosts holiday parties too.

Address: 1574 NJ 23, Butler, NJ 07405
Phone: (973) 850-6646
Hours: Monday to Thursday 11 am to 10 pm, Friday and Saturday 11 am to 11 pm, Sunday 12 to 9 pm
Cuisine: Italian, Pizza
Website: buonasera-restaurant.com

Yuki Hana Sushi

A sushi restaurant on Route 23 North serving sushi, sashimi and Japanese dishes for lunch and dinner. It is a dependable pick for a lighter meal or takeout on the way home.

Address: 1370 Route 23 North, Butler, NJ 07405
Phone: (973) 838-4949
Hours: Tuesday to Thursday 11:30 am to 9 pm, Friday and Saturday 11:30 am to 9:30 pm, closed Sunday and Monday
Cuisine: Sushi, Japanese
Website: yukihanabutler.com

Juancho’s Mexican Restaurante

Mexican cooking on Main Street, open seven days a week from late morning. It is an easy and family friendly choice for tacos and plates, with online ordering for pickup.

Address: 98 Main St, Butler, NJ 07405
Hours: Monday to Thursday 11 am to 9 pm, Friday and Saturday 11 am to 10 pm, Sunday 11 am to 8 pm
Cuisine: Mexican
Website: juanchosmexicanrestaurante.com

Taj Mehar Indian Cuisine

Indian cooking on Main Street, from samosas and pakoras to curries and breads. It keeps long hours and offers online ordering, which makes it a great pick for a takeout night.

Address: 140 Main St, Butler, NJ 07405
Phone: (973) 291-4745
Hours: Tuesday to Sunday 11 am to 10 pm
Cuisine: Indian
Website: tajmehar-indiancuisine.com

100 Proof Bar & Bites

The neighborhood bar on Main Street, with craft cocktails, a sports bar atmosphere and a kitchen that stays open until close. No reservations are needed most nights, and late weekend hours make it the spot for a night out in town.

Address: 227 Main St, Butler, NJ 07405
Phone: (973) 291-4418
Hours: Monday 3 pm to 12 am, closed Tuesday, Wednesday and Thursday 12 pm to 12 am, Friday 12 pm to 2 am, Saturday 11 am to 2 am, Sunday 11 am to 12 am
Cuisine: Bar and Grill
Website: 100proofbar.com

Mariachi Restaurant

Another Mexican option on Main Street, serving authentic Mexican style dishes throughout the day, so it works for an early bite or a relaxed dinner. Call ahead for current hours.

Address: 19 Main St, Butler, NJ 07405
Cuisine: Mexican
Website: tmgweb.wixsite.com

Tips for Dining in Butler

• Several spots close one weekday, often Monday or Tuesday, so check hours before you go.
• Main Street restaurants are close together, so it is easy to grab dinner and walk to 100 Proof for a drink afterward.
• Many of these restaurants offer online ordering, which is handy for a takeout night.
• Heading toward Pompton Lakes or Lincoln Park? Our Lincoln Park restaurant guide has more options a short drive away.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the best restaurant in Butler, NJ?

Butler Family Restaurant on Main Street is a local institution with more than 50 years in town. For dinner, Buonasera on Route 23 is a favorite for Italian food and pizza, and Yuki Hana is the pick for sushi.

Where can I get breakfast in Butler, NJ?

Butler Family Restaurant opens at 7 am every day except Tuesday and serves a full breakfast menu. It is the classic morning stop on Main Street.

Are Butler restaurants open late?

Yes. 100 Proof Bar & Bites on Main Street serves food until close, which is 2 am on Fridays and Saturdays and midnight most other nights it is open. Buonasera stays open until 11 pm on Fridays and Saturdays.

What is there to do in Butler besides eat?

Butler has a walkable Main Street and easy access to the trails and parks of northern Morris County. See our guide to things to do in Butler, NJ for more ideas.

Explore More Morris County Restaurant Guides

Morris County is packed with great dining across dozens of towns. Explore our other restaurant guides to find your next favorite spot:

New for 2026: see our full roundup of the best restaurants in Morris County for our top picks in every town.

• Best Restaurants in Lincoln Park, NJ
• Best Restaurants in Denville, NJ
• Best Restaurants in Parsippany, NJ
• Best Restaurants in Morristown, NJ
• Best Diners in Morris County, NJ
• Best Pizza in Morris County, NJ
• All Morris County Restaurant Reviews

Have a Butler restaurant we should add to this list? Let us know and we will check it out.